17 replies to this topic

[RNG Bitch]

What is your suggestion?: Allow us to exchange barrows items for barrows points at the strange old man.

Is this in OSRS?: No.

Has this suggestion been accepted already?: Not that I am aware of.

How would this benefit Alora?: This would give players the ability to exchange duplicate barrows items in exchange for a small ammount of barrows points - 100-200 points per item exchanged seems reasonable, and would allow players, specifically ironmen, to exchange duplicates for points which they can use to get towards 15k they need to redeem a full set.

 

[Selenagomez]

Gonna stay neutral but it does sound nice

[HoldinAP]

For Ironman, that would be good, but don't make it overpowerd, and another point of doing barrows. Support.

[Aves]

Seems like a nice addition to barrows, but I think it should be limited to ironmen. 

 

Support from me.

[strudelle]

the idea is very interessing but as you said it, it would have to be for very low points so it dont get to op.


 

[Formula One]

I’m neutral on this.

It is a good idea, I’m just skeptical on how it can be worked in order to prevent any abuse.

[Ivy]

I feel like this has been suggested before, but must have been quite a few years back.

I'm neutral on this.

I feel there could be some sort of abuse with this, even though I like the idea.

[Lunchy]

I think this should be ironman only, so I support on that note.

[Krest]

I agree this would be a nice add for ironman SUPPORT

[t6rahiinlane]

only if u can get from one item piece like one avg run points then i would support this. 

[loydd]

hey there ! im neutral aswell.. seems like a good idea but only for ironman ! Support

[Tamber]

I'm not too sure if I'd support this. A big part of obtaining items is RNG-based and it makes getting that last needed item that much more rewarding.

[julsbasement]

only issue is see is the cheap loot being rerolled into karils/ahrims for profit in normies. I feel the pain when going for the log though

[Satan Spawn]

I definately think this should be a option and also ironman only because when you get a duplicate you kind of just alch it/ drop it currently

 

 

 

SUPPORT

[Psyc]

Nah this is way to OP I have something like 40 random barrows dupes I could all exchange to flood the market with Ahrims sets? NO SUPPORT

 

Also, this would be hella easy-scape for irons, barrows is already easy enough with the barrows points and increased drop rates. 

[RNG Bitch]

Nah this is way to OP I have something like 40 random barrows dupes I could all exchange to flood the market with Ahrims sets? NO SUPPORT
 
Also, this would be hella easy-scape for irons, barrows is already easy enough with the barrows points and increased drop rates.

40 x 100 = 4000, all of your dupes are still 11,000 points off of one barrows set, which is not guaranteed to be a desirable set. So based on your argument, your logic does not hold up in regards to “flooding the market”

[Psyc]

40 x 100 = 4000, all of your dupes are still 11,000 points off of one barrows set, which is not guaranteed to be a desirable set. So based on your argument, your logic does not hold up in regards to “flooding the market”

I am not the only player on the sever there are 1000's of barrows pieces and only some are desirable, this would further devalue them but, now thinking about it, it would be a good sink for barrows items that isn't high alching. The amount of points per piece would have to be low though.  

[Omicron]

I'm not sure this is a great idea. The issue is that players will dump their bad duplicates that nobody wants, and use it to bring in more of the higher value items, which would likely just result in lowered prices for those items. We also already make barrows quite a bit easier/faster than OSRS, and have a points system which can result in players obtaining an entire barrows set quite easily.

Your suggestion has been declined, if you feel this was wrongfully done please contact a Forum Moderator+.