10 replies to this topic

[Iron Beavis]

What is your suggestion?:

 

Allow ironmen to update their collection logs with tradable items.

 

Is this in OSRS?:

 

I don't think so, but I also don't think it matters in this case.

 

Has this suggestion been accepted already?:

 

Not as far as I can tell.

 

How would this benefit Alora?:

 

I have a few items that were never added to my log, and I'd like to add them. I'm guessing there are others who are also missing items from their log. Obviously it would be silly if anyone could update their collection log with any item just for buying it, but ironmen can't buy items, so I don't think there would be any harm in adding this.

 

 

Thanks for reading!

 

 - S. Rogen 

 

[Spudmo]

Does the collection log adder, in north of the bank where the altar and rfd quest start is not work?

[Iron Beavis]

No, it does not work for tradable items (or, at least, none of the tradable items that I have tried to add).

[Spudmo]

There was a fix I remember, where for example if you got a d chain from kq, it would fill the log for thermo boss, that was fixed, so I’m assuming for tradable items, if you have gotten an item from elsewhere it would not fill the log. And if there’s still a mistake I think a Bug Report would be more viable.

You can leave the topic up to see more responses aswell


So I did look into this.. looks like it’s only for untradables. With that being said I’m not sure if the code can differentiate between dropped items and items that have been found elsewhere (tradable items)

If so then I do support. Would be a nice qol collection log update

Examples would be Godswords/gdw armour from bloody chest

[Iron Beavis]

Ok, I'll keep that in mind. I considered writing this as a bug report, but I'm missing a pretty broad range of items from the log, and I figured this would be the easiest solution. Perhaps I was mistaken o.0. Thanks!

Good point! I forgot about that kinda stuff.

[Shuika]

For instance fi you got a coal bag from other sources and you are trying to log it as motherload item it wound work just to clare things out

[Sagacious]

I would love to see this implemented as it took me 300m+ Slayer XP to get an Eternal slayer ring drop just around 2 weeks before it was added to the collection log. I'm sure I am not the only one with similar issues.

But I think this should only be for regular IM, HCIM and UIM since GIM and EIM can change partners/groups and trade items in that way so a tradeable item could've been gotten potentially by somebody else.

[Iron Beavis]

I would love to see this implemented as it took me 300m+ Slayer XP to get an Eternal slayer ring drop just around 2 weeks before it was added to the collection log. I'm sure I am not the only one with similar issues.

But I think this should only be for regular IM, HCIM and UIM since GIM and EIM can change partners/groups and trade items in that way so a tradeable item could've be gotten potentially by somebody else.

Another good point! I guess I should have given this a bit more thought before posting haha

[Luka Doncic]

Support as I finished barrows and many other things before the collection log was even added.

 

CBA going back to get dupes, and being a HC I couldn't have gotten them anywhere else.

[1]

Would love to see this implemented.

 

Another thing - if the item has already been combined with another, e.g Primordial Crystal used on Dragon Boots, please can we use the Primordial Boots to complete the Primordial Crystal entry.

[Omicron]

The reason we don't allow this is because there are other ways to obtain items other than the boss itself, even for ironmen. For example, there'd be nothing stopping EIM/GIM players to trade items between each other and logging these items. Not only that, but the bloody/supply chests come to mind, as well as other ways to get items that fit into specific logs that I haven't yet considered.

Your suggestion has been declined, if you feel this was wrongfully done please contact a Forum Moderator+.