17 replies to this topic

[Never Dry]

What is your suggestion?:

Add all graceful pieces with recolors and ring of endurance to the collection log

Is this in OSRS?:

I'm not sure but I believe it is

Has this suggestion been accepted already?:

Not that I've seen

How would this benefit Alora?:

Just give another goal to go for and a little more dopamine hit when unlocking graceful with the recolors

[Tungus]

Yes, I support this. This is worthy of a collectors item slot. 

[J boogs]

I support adding the Graceful set and Ring of Endurance to collection log how they have it like OSRS but keep out all the recolors. I believe the Collection log needs a lot of love right now as we are missing over 500+ items in comparison to OSRS. 

https://oldschool.ru...Rooftop_Agility

[Never Dry]

I support adding the Graceful set and Ring of Endurance to collection log how they have it like OSRS but keep out all the recolors. I believe the Collection log needs a lot of love right now as we are missing over 500+ items in comparison to OSRS. 

https://oldschool.ru...Rooftop_Agility

I personally want the recolors so there’s more point to getting them rather than just fashionscape, also our collection log will never match OSRS to 100% which we have to be okay with. OSRS doesn’t have the custom monkey backpacks and we don’t have a lot of the content osrs has because most players wouldn’t enjoy it either way. But if you feel it’s necessary feel free to make a more in depth suggestion so I, and others, can better understand your POV

[J boogs]

I personally want the recolors so there’s more point to getting them rather than just fashionscape, also our collection log will never match OSRS to 100% which we have to be okay with. OSRS doesn’t have the custom monkey backpacks and we don’t have a lot of the content osrs has because most players wouldn’t enjoy it either way. But if you feel it’s necessary feel free to make a more in depth suggestion so I, and others, can better understand your POV

 

Having 7 sets on there would just be unnecessary in my opinion. Also, yes OSRS has Monkey backpacks in the log just missing Golden comp monkey of course.

[Never Dry]

Having 7 sets on there would just be unnecessary in my opinion. Also, yes OSRS has Monkey backpacks in the log just missing Golden comp monkey of course.

Oh I didn't know I don't really play OSRS thought it was custom to Alora, but I personally think it wouldn't be too much and would like to see it to make it a goal to unlock all sets, but either way I'd be happy just to get more completionist things like this added to the collection log.

[Omicron]

Most of the items we're missing from the log are irrelevant or not obtainable on Alora. Examples include beginner clue entries, teleport scrolls, a lot of master clue items (which are customs on Alora), Shades of Mort'ton, etc... There are hundreds of entries which wouldn't be relevant, but that being said, there are also probably quite a few that would be, and I wouldn't mind expanding the log to include those. I think adding a log for graceful and all the recolours + the ring of endurance would be a good idea, but I'll leave this open for a bit longer to see if players really want that. 

[Luka Doncic]

Would not mind it, I think it should be just the set and let the collection check your inv for it if you got it already.

 

In other words, he picks up whether you have regular or recolored and its just logs it as graceful. 

 

Support.

[Zachhh]

I've been really grinding out the collection log, would be nice to have some more content to grind out for longer. Support from me.

[strudelle]

i would like to see this added, its fun to have more item to grind for the collection log :) support

[Never Dry]

Most of the items we're missing from the log are irrelevant or not obtainable on Alora. Examples include beginner clue entries, teleport scrolls, a lot of master clue items (which are customs on Alora), Shades of Mort'ton, etc... There are hundreds of entries which wouldn't be relevant, but that being said, there are also probably quite a few that would be, and I wouldn't mind expanding the log to include those. I think adding a log for graceful and all the recolours + the ring of endurance would be a good idea, but I'll leave this open for a bit longer to see if players really want that. 

If this gets added I'd also like to make sure people can't donate for the dark dyes and just sell them to complete this unlock. I mean there's other logs completed this way, but I think the more we can avoid P2W for collection log the better

[Omicron]

If this gets added I'd also like to make sure people can't donate for the dark dyes and just sell them to complete this unlock. I mean there's other logs completed this way, but I think the more we can avoid P2W for collection log the better

That's not something we'd do. We never meant to make graceful purchasable through dark dyes, but we only found out it was even possible months after it was added, and decided to just leave it by that point. If we do add graceful sets to the collection log, "The collector" npc will log it for players so that everyone doesn't have to get graceful again, which would already have made that log P2W for the players who got it beforehand. 

[Never Dry]

@Omicron That's understandable, I mean I'd rather have this added than not, more content IMO can't be a bad thing, so I'd say bring it even if some players decided to pay lump sums to unlock it.

[Ivy]

I’m Neutral on this.

If I have to grind a few thousand laps to complete this then so be it.

But also agree with @J boogs, The collection log does need some love.

[1]

Support, would like to see more CL entries.

[To gain]

To add gracefull (agillity part of the Osrs Collection log) Support.

Adding all recolors aswell i'd say no, for the simple reason there are alot of players that have 10k+ marks of grace in their banks meaning its just another buyable.

[Never Dry]

To add gracefull (agillity part of the Osrs Collection log) Support.

Adding all recolors aswell i'd say no, for the simple reason there are alot of players that have 10k+ marks of grace in their banks meaning its just another buyable.

With this logic wouldn't adding regular graceful to the collection log already be just another buyable? Also, not everyone does CL entries to be buyable I think a vast majority of ironmen would enjoy grinding out the colored sets for collection log entries without being P2W for them personally and the select few with money to spare will do it if they want it's a win win that either scenario wouldn't hurt the other.

[Omicron]

Your suggestion has been declined, if you feel this was wrongfully done please contact a Forum Moderator+. We've declined this since it seems unreasonable to complete a log with all of the graceful recolours, however we've added a log that'll have the regular graceful set, the ring of endurance, and the dark acorn, as well as marks of grace.