25 replies to this topic

[I give down]

Hey all :) was just thinking that it would make sense to add achieving the clue scroll sack (must complete 150 clue scrolls) to the list of requirements for completionist cape as it's all about completing the game in all aspects.

[Nhk]

I agree, there's a bunch of miscellaneous stuff on there but it fits into "completing the game in all aspects" as you said perfectly.

Support

[Zach McCoy]

I totally support this, nice suggestion.

[22]

I like this idea. Support.

[rafffstaa]

I don't think clue scrolls > clue sack is really a completionist item. If this goes through then we would also need to consider full graceful set, diary rewards from daily and such.

 

cool idea

 

no support from me though

[I give down]

I don't think clue scrolls > clue sack is really a completionist item. If this goes through then we would also need to consider full graceful set, diary rewards from daily and such.

 

cool idea

 

no support from me though

Someone doesn't wanna lose their monkey!

Edit: Yeah, I think there probably is more things they could add to the list that you detailed as well.

[Iron Gurt]

No support. I'm going to have to agree with what rafffstaa said. It makes perfect sense, cool idea, but it's like a bonus achievement to the game. The Scroll Sack is it's OWN UNIQUE item in it's own unique category being clue scrolls. If there was such a thing as a clue scroll cape similar to the music/achievement cape then I would support this. 

[I give down]

No support. I'm going to have to agree with what rafffstaa said. It makes perfect sense, cool idea, but it's like a bonus achievement to the game. The Scroll Sack is it's OWN UNIQUE item in it's own unique category being clue scrolls. If there was such a thing as a clue scroll cape similar to the music/achievement cape then I would support this. 

I totally understand what you mean, but in my own opinion a completionist cape is meant to be all encompassing. When you slap that thing on it should represent that you've completed most things achievable in game as possible. You shouldn't have to tell people you've got that sack, the cape should speak for itself. :)

[Jisoo]

Support!

 

I like the idea, it's only fair that 150 clues is a COMPLETIONIST requirement, otherwise the comp monkey wouldn't feel right if you haven't "completed" the game. 

[MT]

It would definitely be a great addition to comp reqs. Support.

[Aritus]

I like the idea, but the issue I'm facing with is the fact that is has no advantages for us when the clue scrolls are added towards the completionist requirements. It feels like working for something that we already possess without any pros. In my opinion, if you suggest this then you should think of what we will get in return to make it worth. 

 

Neutral for now.

[Iron baaail]

this is not a bad idea, support.

[IM Moe]

I like the idea with adding more to the completionist monkey, but not acquiring the clue scroll sack as one of them. That has nothing to do with completing the game, that is like a sub-achievement you can choose to do for it's own award. No support. 

[Sassa fras]

"It's all about completing the game in all aspects"

 

This is really the crux of the debate, and where I disagree with you. If we're talking about actually "completing" the game, there are tons of requirements that could be added to comp cape: arbitrary amounts of boss and PVP kills, all pets, all untradeables, 4.6b XP, the list goes on and on. For me, wearing a comp cape signifies you've completed a certain amount of goals in all aspects of the game, not that you have finished everything in the game.

 

I'd suggest changing the clue scroll requirement to 10 of each tier given that the current one is pretty weak, but don't really see the need to tie the sack of scrolls to comp cape. No support

[Turner skill]

is the also because you have already completed 150 clues? 

[Ragragrag46]

fuck cluescrolls , i dont want to do 150 clues for nothing to wear it again

[ZeZeOne]

I think cluescrolls are up to the individual, not a requirement for the completionist cape

[To gain]

No support for the following reason: the comp monkey is a reward for completing all the quests, music cape, all achievements, 1b total XP, having 3 200m skills and completing the inferno successfully.

Completing 150 clue scrolls has its own and separate reward which is the sack of scrolls.

Besides that OSRS has no comp cape, so the comp monkey is Alora's way of rewarding the player for completing all the requirements.

If osrs releases a comp cape then and only then you can look at adding things to the reqs.

[Bhaal]

No support for the clue scroll idea, but I do think that all Quests should be a requirement (like on OSRS), as currently you can get it without them.

[Dumdum]

As someone who is pretty invested in UIM currently, I can't support this. I like the idea, but it would make monkey so beyond annoying on UIM when its already difficult enough. Clues are just no bueno on UIM