I've been around for a short time, and it seems like the loyalty store is a hot topic among players. A few players have started threads suggesting updates, but they mostly just want changes without really sharing any cool ideas for new items. I thought I’d take a shot at sharing some ideas myself.
Cursed Goblin Staff - 25,000 loyalty points
https://oldschool.ru...ed_goblin_staff
Tyras Helm - 25,000 loyalty points
https://oldschool.ru...ki/w/Tyras_helm
Fancier Boots - 30,000 loyalty points
https://oldschool.ru...w/Fancier_boots
Zealot's Robes - 25,000 loyalty points per piece
https://oldschool.ru.../Zealot's_robes
Dark Squall Robes - 50,000 loyalty points per piece
https://oldschool.ru...rk_Squall_robes
Poet's Jacket - 50,000 loyalty points
https://oldschool.ru...w/Poet's_jacket
Helmet of The Moon - 50,000 loyalty points
https://oldschool.ru...met_of_the_moon
Gadderhammer - 100,000 loyalty points
https://oldschool.ru.../w/Gadderhammer
Queen's Secateurs (make it wieldable and act as magic secateurs) - 250,000 loyalty points
https://oldschool.ru...een's_secateurs
Zanik Pet (NPC that technically functions as a pet during a few quests in the original game) - 1,000,000 loyalty points
https://oldschool.ru...pe.wiki/w/Zanik